Hey Ben, All the dome light door switches for 2nd gen F bodies that I have seen are metal. So, should be normal for the paint to rub off on the door where the pin makes contact. If memory serves me correctly the switch itself is only a ground circuit. When the pin is pushed in it does not groud out (earth as you say). Once the door is open and the pin protrudes it grounds (earths) internally through the switch which is screwed into the body of the car and completes the circuit allowing the light to illuminate.