That whole corner of the door is pretty much gone.
I was thinking I'd rather just go with a replacement, but living in North Dakota there aren't a whole lot of parts floating around. I've seen some go really reasonably on eBay, but shipping was more than the door. Early this summer I'll be heading to Pennsylvania, hopefully everything works out and I can find one to pick up on my way back.
It is a true Y88, the grills are not painted gold, and I don't know if the snowflakes are correct or not as they were painted black somewhere along the line. But the rest of the trim seems to be correct.