you took the words right out of my mouth....
I like the 17s better in the pics but only slightly... the orig rims are very close IMO,,,, I like the 17s cause they look sharper and cleaner.
so hear me out,,, I know for a fact the reason most aren't likeing them as much as they thought is because of the stance. Our minds are almost trained to think larger rim = lower stance,,,but its the opposite. The stance on any car is really key and changeing the rims and tires will offset all that in your mind,,,even if you retain the same diam tire/ aka wheel gap. The modern look to me is more about a lower stance then the larger wheels. I really think the car needs to come down atleast 2 inches or untill there is a 1-2 inch wheel gap....and then add a 1/2 to 1 inch onto the rear gap.
As a test I will show a pic of my previuosly owned car.... to me this is a modern look ppl want.... its got that big rim look right......
....
well get this,,,, that's the stock 16" rims and tire size.... It is only lowered, and it almost fools you to think its larger rims and tires but its not. Now contrast that to a 2nd gen,,, I would assume if he lowered his car right it will make the 17" rims look even larger.