hehehe, gotta love you Rick, always putting a smile on my face. Everything is cleaned up now however, my arms still hurt!
Well, I believe that two of the holes will line up so I'll go down this week and get the puller again (rent it for free) and try just two holes. It certainly will not come off with a pulley, I tried to muscle it a little and she's on there. I didn't try just two bolts because I thought I might damage it and I really can't afford a new one but it seems everyone I've spoken to says to just use two holes and everything should be fine so... that's what I'll do.
If everything goes well I'll post over at my original thread moving forward. I posted this new post because I wanted attention drawn to my dilemma.